
Healing Doesn’t Change Who Wants You. It Changes Who You Want.
Updated: Nov 1
Finding 40 | Love, Relationships & the Messy Business of Healing
I was watching one of those couples counseling shows the other day. You know the ones where you’re sitting on your couch judging everybody else’s relationship decisions while conveniently forgetting a few of your own? Yeah, one of those.
Anyway, the counselor said something that caught my attention. I’m paraphrasing, but the message was basically that healthy, healed people aren’t attracted to unhealthy, unhealed people. That people who haven’t dealt with their own issues tend to find themselves attracted to other people who haven’t dealt with theirs.
And I sat there thinking about that long after the show was over.
Now, my first thought was, well, dang. That’s a little harsh.
Because what exactly does a completely healed person look like? Do they come with a certificate? Is there a graduation ceremony? Do we get a little sash that says, “Congratulations, you are now emotionally available and free of childhood trauma”?
Because I’d like to know where we’re signing up.
I don’t particularly like referring to people as broken, either. We’ve all been through things. We’ve all developed habits, fears, and ways of protecting ourselves that made sense at one point in our lives, even if they aren’t particularly helpful anymore.
But the more I thought about what that counselor said, the more I started wondering whether there was some truth to it.
Not necessarily that unhealthy people attract unhealthy people, but that sometimes we’re drawn to relationships that feel familiar, even when that familiarity isn’t necessarily good for us.
And that thought made me a little uncomfortable.
Probably because I’ve spent a significant part of my adult life trying to understand myself, my relationships, and the decisions I’ve made along the way.
I’ve been married. I’ve been divorced. I’ve rebuilt a life I once thought would look very different. I’ve done the self-reflection, recognized patterns, questioned my own behavior, and learned some pretty expensive lessons about love.
Emotionally expensive, to be clear. Although divorce isn’t exactly cheap either.
And after all of that, I’d like to believe I’ve grown.
Actually, I know I have.
But here’s the part nobody really prepares you for.
You can do an incredible amount of work on yourself and still encounter situations that make you question how much you’ve really learned.
When Familiar Feels Like Love
I think one of the hardest things to admit is that sometimes what attracts us to someone isn’t necessarily what’s good for us.
We talk about chemistry like it’s this magical thing that happens when two people are meant to be together. And sometimes it is a beautiful part of a genuine connection.
But chemistry can also exist between two people who have absolutely no business building a life together.
That’s the part we don’t always want to acknowledge.
I’ve experienced connections that felt different from anything I’d known before. The kind where the conversation comes naturally, the affection feels genuine, and you find yourself opening up in ways you didn’t expect.
And when you’ve spent years learning how to be independent, how to survive difficult things, and how to take care of yourself, having someone make you feel like you can finally soften a little can be incredibly powerful.
Especially when you’ve spent so much of your life being the strong one.
But one of the things I’ve come to understand is that feeling safe with someone and actually being emotionally safe with them aren’t always the same thing.
That’s a difficult distinction.
Someone can be gentle with you. They can hold you, listen to you, say beautiful things, and make you feel like you’ve finally found the kind of love you’ve been waiting for.
And still not be capable of offering the honesty, consistency, or commitment that a healthy relationship requires.
For a long time, I thought emotional safety was largely about how someone made me feel in their presence.
But emotional safety also has a lot to do with how someone’s behavior holds up when you’re not around.
Because tenderness without truth isn’t emotional safety.
It’s tenderness.
And while tenderness is beautiful, it cannot carry an entire relationship by itself.
Maybe Healing Changes What We Find Attractive
Here’s where I started to understand what the counselor might have been getting at.
Think about the things you found attractive when you were younger.
Not just physically, but emotionally.
The mysterious person. The one who was hard to figure out. The one whose attention felt like something you had to earn.
At some point, many of us confused being pursued with being valued, being needed with being loved, and intensity with intimacy.
And I can admit that there have been times in my life when being the person someone needed made me feel important.
I was good at being understanding. Good at making excuses for people. Good at seeing their potential, sometimes more clearly than I was willing to see their actual behavior.
Give me a complicated person with a difficult past and a little emotional potential, and apparently, at certain points in my life, I thought I had found myself a project.
The problem with being good at understanding people is that you can become very good at explaining away things that should probably concern you.
You understand why they struggle with communication. You understand why they have trust issues. You understand why vulnerability is difficult for them.
And sometimes all that understanding leaves very little room for you to ask whether the relationship is actually meeting your needs.
I’m not saying we shouldn’t have compassion for people. I believe everyone deserves compassion.
But there’s a difference between understanding someone’s pain and making yourself responsible for absorbing the consequences of it.
You can recognize someone’s potential without signing up to wait indefinitely for them to become that person.
And you can care about someone deeply while accepting that caring about them doesn’t automatically make the relationship healthy.
Maybe that’s part of what healing changes.
Not necessarily the people who approach us, but the people we continue making room for.
The Part About Healing That Nobody Likes Talking About
I have a problem with the idea that we attract people based entirely on how healed we are.
Because taken too far, that philosophy starts sounding suspiciously like blaming people for the ways they’ve been mistreated.
And I’m not buying that.
Sometimes people lie.
Sometimes people misrepresent themselves.
Sometimes someone presents a version of themselves that is completely different from the person their actions eventually reveal.
You can be self-aware, emotionally mature, and genuinely committed to building something healthy and still find yourself loving someone who wasn’t being honest with you.
That doesn’t mean you failed some cosmic healing test.
It means you’re human.
I think we have to be careful about turning every painful relationship into evidence that there’s something wrong with the person who got hurt.
There are lessons to learn from our choices, absolutely. There are patterns worth examining and moments when we need to take responsibility for ignoring what was right in front of us.
But there’s also a difference between ignoring a red flag and being given information that simply wasn’t true.
And I think women, especially, can be a little too quick to turn someone else’s behavior into another opportunity to criticize ourselves.
Why didn’t I see it?
How could I have believed that?
What is it about me that keeps attracting this?
Those questions can be useful when we’re examining our own patterns. But they can also become another way of holding ourselves responsible for decisions someone else made.
I’ve spent enough years questioning myself to know that not every painful experience requires me to find something defective within myself.
Sometimes the lesson isn’t that we need to become completely different people.
Sometimes the lesson is that we need to trust the people we’ve already become.
And sometimes the person who hurt us was simply making choices we couldn’t control.
Both things can be true.
What Happens When You’ve Healed, But Life Still Hurts?
I think this is one of the more frustrating parts of personal growth.
You can look back at your life and recognize just how much you’ve changed.
You can remember the things you once tolerated, the excuses you once made, and the situations you once convinced yourself were normal.
And you can feel genuinely proud of the person you’ve become.
I know what it took to rebuild after divorce. I know what it feels like to keep showing up for your children, your career, your responsibilities, and everybody who depends on you while privately trying to put pieces of your own life back together.
That kind of experience changes you.
It teaches you things about yourself that you probably never would have volunteered to learn.
And somewhere along the way, I think it’s easy to start believing that all those lessons should protect us from ever making another mistake in love.
Surely, by our 40s, we’ve learned enough to avoid some of the nonsense we entertained in our 20s.
Apparently, life does not offer continuing education credits for surviving your previous relationships.
Because the truth is, we can be wiser than we’ve ever been and still get hurt.
We can recognize unhealthy patterns and still find ourselves disappointed by people.
We can know exactly what we deserve and still struggle with accepting that someone isn’t capable of giving it to us.
And none of that automatically means we haven’t healed.
I think we sometimes confuse healing with becoming immune to pain.
As if doing enough work on ourselves should eventually make us incapable of being disappointed, deceived, or heartbroken.
But that’s not how relationships work.
We don’t get to know everything about another person the moment we meet them. We make decisions based on what we know, what we observe, and what someone chooses to show us.
And sometimes new information changes how we understand a relationship.
One of the things I’ve learned is that missing someone doesn’t necessarily mean they belong in your life. Sometimes we spend more time questioning why something ended than considering whether it was ever truly giving us what we needed.
Maybe healing isn’t about never experiencing pain again.
Maybe it’s about learning how to experience it without completely losing ourselves in the process.
And I say learning because I don’t believe that’s something we ever completely master.
I Don’t Want to Become Hard Just Because I’ve Been Hurt
One thing I refuse to accept is the idea that the solution to heartbreak is becoming so guarded that nobody can get close enough to hurt us again.
I’ve already spent enough of my life being strong out of necessity.
I don’t want to spend the rest of it treating love like a threat that needs to be managed.
I still believe in love.
I still believe in connection, affection, partnership, and the kind of relationship where two people genuinely enjoy doing life together.
I want the ordinary things, too. The shared routines, the conversations about absolutely nothing, the comfort of having someone who wants to be there.
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting that.
What I do think deserves more attention is how we determine whether someone is actually capable of building it with us.
Because loving someone deeply doesn’t automatically mean they’re the right person for us.
Our feelings tell us something about our experience.
Their behavior tells us something about the relationship.
And we need to pay attention to both.
You can feel an incredible connection with someone and still need to ask whether their actions support the kind of life you want.
You can love the way someone makes you feel and still recognize that certain behaviors are unacceptable.
And you can be disappointed that something didn’t work out without convincing yourself that you somehow failed at love.
That last one might take a little practice.
Maybe We’ve Been Asking the Wrong Question
When I first heard that counselor’s statement, I interpreted it as meaning that once we heal, we stop attracting people who haven’t done their own work.
But after sitting with it, I think that’s too simplistic.
I don’t believe we’re ever completely finished healing. I don’t think emotionally healthy people are perfect, either. They still have insecurities, bad days, disagreements, and things they’re working through.
The difference, at least the way I see it, is a willingness to be honest, accountable, and responsible for how our behavior affects other people.
And maybe as we grow, those qualities become more attractive than the things that used to impress us.
Maybe consistency becomes more appealing than intensity.
Maybe emotional maturity starts mattering more than romantic gestures.
Maybe we stop being so impressed by someone’s ability to say the right things and start paying closer attention to whether they actually do them.
I don’t know that personal growth means every unhealthy dynamic immediately becomes unattractive.
I wish it worked that way.
But I do think growth makes us more aware of the difference between what feels good in a moment and what is actually good for our lives.
And I think that’s progress, even when it doesn’t feel particularly impressive.
There’s also something freeing about realizing we don’t have to turn every relationship into a success story to prove we’ve grown.
Sometimes something can be meaningful and still not be right.
Sometimes we can miss someone and still understand why the relationship wasn’t sustainable.
Sometimes we can appreciate what a relationship taught us without pretending everything about it was beautiful.
And sometimes the lesson isn’t about the other person at all.
It’s about what we were willing to accept, what we believed love required of us, and whether those beliefs still make sense for the people we’re becoming.
So maybe the counselor was onto something after all.
Maybe healing really does change who we’re attracted to. Or maybe it changes what we’re willing to overlook once the initial attraction wears off.
I suspect it’s a little of both.
But there’s one thought I keep coming back to, and it’s not particularly comfortable.
What if some of the things we’ve called love over the years were really just things we’d learned to tolerate?
And what if becoming healthier means being willing to look at those things differently, even when doing so forces us to reconsider relationships we once believed were everything we wanted?
I don’t have a neat answer for that.
I’m still figuring out which parts of my past were love, which parts were survival, and which parts were simply familiar.
And maybe that’s part of Finding 40.
Not reaching some magical age where we suddenly have everything figured out, but becoming willing to question things we’ve believed about ourselves and relationships for most of our lives.
Because perhaps the real measure of healing isn’t whether unhealthy people find us attractive.
Maybe it’s whether we still find unhealthy relationships appealing once we recognize them for what they are.
And that leaves me with one final thought.
If you met someone today, knowing everything you now know about love, relationships, and yourself, would you still choose the same kind of person you’ve always chosen?
Or would the person you’ve become finally make a different choice?
E.K. Baldwin
Finding 40




Comments